critiques protocolaires d’internet: scuttlebutt et ipfs

5000 - 8000 mots à envoyer pour le 25/02

introduction - 1000 mots

établir le concept de critique protocolaire

établir les précédentes critiques d’internet:

établir la question principale: comment se constitue une critique protocolaire d’internet?

quels sont les points communs de la forme, et les divergences de contenus?


justifier le choix de ces deux projets (points communs et différences)

A protocol is a set of procedural rules, information formats, and other conventions which, if followed by the communicating entities, enable their conversation to proceed smoothly and without confusion or error. Communication protocols naturally fall into a hierarchy of levels.src

in this paper wer’re at the application layer: influential to the user, but also generalistic


1 - analyse de ipfs - 1500 mots

1.1 description (500 mots)

The IPFS is not just a theoretical or academic experiment. It is a working software system (although still in alpha) that can be downloaded and switched on right now src this is the point of protocol critique

section sur applications - web UI has a map of the world -> global - also what it is associated with -> filecoin, blockchain (brave), multiformats, IPLD (fancy name for merkle dag), libp2p

check the community?

1.2 discours (500 mots)

“If you don’t pin your content to IPFS, it goes bye-bye. And if the server pinning your resources ever goes offline and no one else has it pinned, it’s gone forever. That’s why a market has opened up for services like Pinata, which aim to be permanent pinning services. So you still end up with a centralized business framework even if the technology itself is decentralized, in that, if you don’t have the means to provide your own distributed infrastructure, you’re going to have to pay someone who does.” src

discussion board

1.3 limites et nature de la critique (500 mots)

surtout sur la disparition des données!

on a vu une tentative d’universel. maintenant, on va voir comment on peut réutiliser des protocoles pour arriver à une vision du monde différente?

2 - analyse de ssb - 1500 mots

2.1 description

2.2 discours

2.3 conclusions et direction de la critique

3 - rapport protocolaires à l’espace et au temps - 1000 mots

3.1 le temps

3.2 l’espace

univers parallèle avec le web portal universalisme et localisme

3.3 les questions de déterminismes techniques

sha-512 vs. human positions